We review two of the new Kindles.

The Kindle Colorsoft with the page turn cover on is on the left. On the right is the Kindle Paperwhite. Lindsey Choo/Morning Brew Inc.
Disclosure: Companies may send us products to test, but they never pay for our opinions. Our recommendations are unbiased and unfiltered, and Tech Brew may earn a commission if you buy through our links.
I’m a certified e-reader loyalist: I want to carry a hefty fantasy novel without staring at my glowing phone, and I want it to fit in my tiny purse. I’ve hung on to my old Kindle Basic 2019 for years for the most boring reason possible—nothing is wrong with it.
I was skeptical that a new Kindle could improve my life, since my old one was doing the job just fine. But then I saw the lineup’s new colors and sleek redesign, and suddenly “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it” sounded like something my husband made up.
How we tested them: Over a month, I read at least two full-length books each on the Kindle Colorsoft ($320) and Paperwhite ($250) Signature Editions, one with the Page-Turn Cover ($80) on and one without. I brought them with me everywhere—on the subway, to coffee shops, to the park, and to bed. I borrow most of my books from my local library through the Libby app, so I just sent them straight to my Kindle account, and they synced to every Kindle I own. The cover, which snaps on magnetically, has physical buttons I can press to turn pages. And to see what color actually adds, I flipped through a cookbook on the Colorsoft.
The Good: Both Kindles are very customizable—you can tweak the font, brightness, and warmth to your liking. They also respond much faster to the touch, and library books that used to take a few minutes to load on my old Kindle showed up almost immediately. The battery life was impressive: Each device still had more than half of its battery left after reading the two books, while my old Kindle tapped out every two books or so. The colors on the Colorsoft were slightly muted but plenty vivid for book covers and visual elements.
The Bad: At 7 inches, the new Kindles are a bit bigger than my old 6-inch one. That’s great for screen space, but as they’re made of aluminum, it also means they’re heavier: At 8.1 ounces, they weigh about 2 ounces more (roughly the weight of a tennis ball) than my old one, and are harder to hold with one hand. Having physical buttons with the cover is lovely, but the default button setup was so annoying (the top button turns forward, which forced me to reach my thumb up each time) that I had to dig into the settings to swap them. At $80, the cover felt more like a nice-to-have than a game changer (it’s also only compatible with the already pricier Signature Editions).
Verdict: ✅ Signal—for the Paperwhite (for everyday readers) and Colorsoft (for pretty gadget lovers). ❌ Noise—for the Page-Turn Cover, which didn’t earn its price tag. —LC